11/10/2026

California Employment Law 2027: New Laws, Higher Penalties

Webinar Overview

Beginning July 1, 2027, an automated system cannot be the sole basis for firing an employee.
Repayment clauses need a fresh review before the next signature.
Repeated failures to file employee pay reports can carry a penalty of up to $1,000 per employee.
The state minimum wage rises to $17.40 per hour on January 1, 2027.
Willfully obstructing a Cal/OSHA safety inspection becomes a misdemeanor on January 1, 2027.
The designated-person Paid Family Leave expansion starts July 1, 2028.

Meet the Speakers

Angela Rho
Angela Rho
Partner
Partner in Medina McKelvey’s Advice & Counsel Practice Group who helps California employers navigate complex employment laws, reduce risk, and make defensible workplace decisions.
View Full Bio ›
Melissa Whitehead
Melissa Whitehead
Partner, AWI-CH
Partner who helps employers navigate workplace disputes, investigations, and compliance challenges across California workplaces.
View Full Bio ›
Elizabeth Levy
Elizabeth Levy
Partner
Partner who advises and defends employers on wage and hour compliance, PAGA exposure, and workplace policies.
View Full Bio ›

Transcript

[Angela Rho] (0:05 - 0:17)
Good morning, everybody. All right, let me just make sure I've got my screen here so I can see what is going on. Okay, good morning.

[Melissa Whitehead] (0:17 - 0:29)
I always say the beginning is like pop, like we're watching popcorn pop, we could pop, we can see the little participants number going up as people join and like as it starts to slow down, then we've given people enough time to get in there.

[Angela Rho] (0:30 - 0:44)
Perfect, perfect, and I see a raised hand already, a couple of raised hands. I'm trying to figure out how to, oh, okay, all right, an echo.

[Melissa Whitehead] (0:45 - 0:51)
Is there an echo when we talk? Is that one person or are multiple people hearing that? So I don't hear it on my end.

[Elizabeth Levy] (0:52 - 0:55)
I don't, I don't hear an echo on my end when you guys talk.

[Melissa Whitehead] (0:56 - 0:58)
Okay, so it sounds like it's one person.

[Elizabeth Levy] (0:58 - 1:00)
Maybe one person. Other people say, it's okay.

[Melissa Whitehead] (1:01 - 1:01)
Okay.

[Angela Rho] (1:03 - 1:12)
Is it me? Oh, shoot. I don't, I also hear an echo.

No.

[Elizabeth Levy] (1:13 - 1:19)
I think it was one person who was having an echo on their, on their end.

[Angela Rho] (1:20 - 2:27)
Yes, the suggestion is to close one of your browsers because you may be getting the browser and the app. You guys are the best, I will say. Our technology is not my strong suit.

We are now at 228 participants. We're two minutes in. I'm going to say maybe we just roll.

I like it. All right. Everybody ready?

Cool. All right. Well, good morning to most of you and welcome to the Medina McKelvey 2027 California New Employment Laws webinar.

I will come up with a better title for that next year. My name is Angela Rho and I'm a partner and co-lead of the Advice and Counsel Practice Group. I am joined today by my two phenomenal partners, Melissa Whitehead and Elizabeth Levy.

Now, before we begin, please give us a thumbs up in the chat if you can see the slides on your screen. Thumbs up. I'm seeing nothing.

So hopefully you all can love it.

[Melissa Whitehead] (2:27 - 2:27)
Okay.

[Angela Rho] (2:27 - 4:15)
Thank you all so much. You can see it. In addition to that, all attendees will have access to a question and answer Q&A box.

So please put your questions in that box, that chat, instead of this main chat. And then we'll go ahead and take a look at those and answer as we go along. You guys are the best.

I love this. We have people who listen, paying attention. Fantastic.

All right. Moving on to the next slide. This would not be a lawyer's webinar if I didn't have this lawyerly disclaimer here.

Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. The information provided in this webinar is not legal advice. So please reach out to us separately or one of your own attorneys if you have particular questions about a set of facts that you want to go over.

Please consult an attorney. But this is informational only. Beyond that, I have also been asked to remind everybody that CLE credit is pending.

So tune in for the CLE code towards the end of the presentation. Elizabeth can discuss those details further when we get there. And yes, there will be a replay of this webinar available on our website.

And our team will also be emailing out the materials to you hopefully later today. Now, what are we talking about today? Here's the agenda.

As you can see, we're going to start with everyone's favorite topic, AI, and we're going to work our way through contracts, leave, wage and hour, workplace violence, PAGA, and your favorite, we will be having a Q&A at the end of the session. So I'm going to pass it to Melissa to start us off for the day.

[Melissa Whitehead] (4:15 - 19:50)
All right. Thank you very much. For those of you who don't know me, I'm Melissa.

I'm another one of the advice partners here. And I get to start with that little topic that so few people care about, which is AI and privacy. You know, I will say the big picture of what I'm about to get into is that as California loves to do, much of what we would suggest as best practices is now being legislated and is now required.

That's the big picture from my perspective. The first new law I'm going to talk about in this little umbrella is SB 947, the No Robo Bosses Act. And essentially, it boils down to what that little subheading there says, is we can use AI as a tool.

There can be algorithms. You can do all these things. But ultimately, a human has to make final decisions when it comes to discipline, firing.

That's what this law says. I would also expand that to hiring, leave decisions, all of those things. A human needs to be involved.

You may remember a few years ago when AI tools were kind of, you know, not as many people were using them. It was a lot more cutting edge. It's still pretty cutting edge, but it was newer.

There were some cases that came out of the EEOC. The EEOC put out some guidance that essentially said, hey, dummies, don't forget about disparate impact. This is separate from that, but I want to highlight it for a second, which says, essentially, even if you're using these automated systems and you're setting in, for example, the cases that came out back then were, hey, we're going to filter our resumes through our AI tool, which we have set to only pull resumes that have X degree, you know, whatever the requirement is.

I think in that one, it was a certain degree requirement or graduated a certain year or later so that they're getting a certain number of experience being the idea. The problem was, even though the intentions were good, the AI tool was using that to, you know, impact a group of people. One of the cases, it was age.

In another case, it was, I think, gender, disparately. So there was a group of people who were being more negatively impacted than others, and the courts and the EEOC said, yeah, you don't get out of jail free just because you use, you know, your intentions were clearly good. It was AI.

You were intentionally not hiring people of a certain age. So that's what sort of started this ball rolling, and now here we are and we have substantially more legislation. So this law goes into effect in July, so you have some time, but essentially, again, it's saying you can't discipline or fire based solely on an automated decision system without having a human look at it and sort of stamp approval or not on that decision.

It also adds a requirement that you have to use, if you do use AI for any of these decision makings, even, you know, even if you do the human step at the end, you have to give written notice to the employee after use, and so you're going to want to, you know, click over to this, your move, you're going to want to have a template, but if you are using AI, you're going to want to have a template you could use for that. You can't use an ADS to infer protected traits or to retaliate, which sounds common sense, and I tried to think about how this would actually, you know, what would people be doing that would trigger this, and one of the things that kind of came to mind would be if you have some sort of automated system that's tracking absences, for example, and then automatically kicking out some sort of, you know, auto generating a warning, for example, you've had X number of unexcused absences, well, if somebody has absences because they have a leave or they're in the process of discussing accommodations or something like that, that could lead to a problem, so again, that's why you always are going to want a human to look at it who has that type of knowledge and information. It also adds some teeth to this now.

It's $500 per violation and may lead to PAGA claims. There may be some PAGA overlap there, which is the nightmare of everyone, so you want to be really mindful of this, so, you know, in terms of practical steps of what you should do is think through inventory every tool you have that might fall under this category, and I say it that way because I don't want you to just think, well, I don't use Claude for this type of thing, I don't use ChatGPT, but do you have a system that automatically scores things or ranks things or flags absences, like I mentioned, things like that, that's likely to qualify here. Identify the practice of the policy of who the human reviewer is going to be, whose job it is to check that, probably somebody within HR or your HR equivalent is who you're going to want doing that. I'm not suggesting you should create a policy that identifies this in the handbook, but internally you want to set those practices now, those policies, processes.

Add the post-use notice if you're using an automated decision system to your termination checklist, because if you use AI, even if it's just a flag it and then you made the decision, you're going to have to give notice that you used an ADS in that system, so you're going to add that. And if you have a vendor working on these things with you, you want to get this information from them, do you have a human looking at it, et cetera, although I would recommend you have a human in your organization look at these things, but don't think that using a vendor, I'm just going to assume it's all good and I'm not worried about it anymore, because probably your contract with them says you would still be liable if they're getting it wrong. That's just my guess if I was looking at a crystal ball. So that's that one in AI and then there's, wait, there's more.

This is actually, it's not a new bill, but we want to flag it. If you are in a business that's covered by California Privacy Protection Agency, very proud of myself for pulling that acronym out. If you are a CCPA covered business, then in addition to that post-use notice we just talked about, you also need a pre-use notice plus opt-out options or a human appeal.

So in other words, somebody can say potentially you can't use AI for me or hey, I get the right to appeal this decision that was made with an automated decision system. So there's other requirements. I'm not going to get too in the weeds on that, but just know that if you are CCPA covered and arguably it covers more than the California bill I just talked about, because they talk about just automated tools.

So where I said that things like if you have an ADP that flags absences for you, it probably falls under the bill I just talked about, it almost definitely is going to fall here under CCPA. So if you're not sure, that is a whole analysis in the weeds that your attorney, even if we are your attorney, you should reach out to us separately to see if you're covered by the CCPA. And if you are, now is a good time because this compliance is due by January 1, the other bill is July, but this is a good time to sit down and think through your tools.

What are you using? What do we need to do to comply? Do we need the pre-use notice?

Do we need the post-use notice? Do we need to assign a human to look at these things or is that already happening and we just need to document it? Sit down and make that whole plan now.

Have the notices ready now. You never want to be in a situation where you have to create the document when you need it for these types of pre-use and post-use notices. That's just adding stress you don't need in your life.

And then CCPA also has risk assessment requirements where you, it's essentially saying you have to periodically audit these things. Either you have to do a risk assessment before you implement things and then on certain schedules and you have to report that to the regulating agency. I'm blanking on who regulates this one now.

Oh, maybe they have their own. I think they have their own CCPA agency, right? I see Angela nodding.

So I think I'm on the right track. It might be the AG. I'm trying to remember too.

Yeah, it might be. So in any event, there's somebody that you will have to send those risk assessments to on, there's a schedule. So anyway, I'm not going to get into the weeds of that, but if you are covered, put those risk assessment deadlines on your calendar.

I would recommend working with counsel because it's very ticky tacky and detailed. Okay, I think we've got one more in AI and then I'll take a quick look at the Q&A and make sure I'm not missing anything before we move to the next topic. I think this is a lot, oh no, there's two more in AI world.

Okay, so many of you probably are aware of the WARN Act and CalWARN which says certain group layoffs, group terminations trigger these WARN notices, both Federal WARN and California WARN. You have to give 60 days notice. There's very specific requirements.

This new bill, new law amends that notice to add a category that says if you are using AI or automation as a substantial cause of the mass layoff. So maybe you've automated something that people used to do or for the relocation or etc. Then the WARN notice has to include, there's a new list of information that you have to include about the effective job functions, the AI system you use, etc.

And here's a fun fact, what does substantial cause mean? I don't know, nobody knows. They didn't think that was necessary to include in the bill.

They like to keep it fun. Us lawyers think of that as job security. So we don't know.

But at the bottom line is if AI or automation is a factor at all, I would suggest meeting with counsel and thinking through, should we do this? Do we need to do this? Do we need to include it?

Note that this is a CalWARN Act revision that doesn't apply to Federal. If I was looking at my crystal ball, I would say it probably will eventually, but it's not yet, but it is for us here. So if you are in the unfortunate situation of doing a mass layoff or one of these types of relocations where you're closing a whole plant, for example, make sure as always, this isn't new.

You should be documenting the business reason for the reduction in force and decide early whether you think that you're going to fall on the side that automation or AI is a substantial cause such that you have to add these new categories of information to your WARN notice. We always say treat the notice as public. Assume it will be publicly disclosed, available.

So you want to be mindful what you put in there. And then the SB 16, 617 content, that little note, that was a bill that came out in 2025 that just added other things. Primarily, if you remember, had to do with like assistance programs and things like that.

If you're offering assistance to the workers you're laying off, you have to include that information too. So basically the too long, don't want to read it on this one is that there's a lot more things you have to put on that lovely CalWARN notice. So you probably, if you are on this webinar, I'm guessing there's a decent chance that you're calling a lawyer.

If you are in this category, this increases the importance of doing that. That's the takeaway I would say for this. There are even more requirements.

And then finally on the AI and privacy piece, we get a lot of questions, or at least I do, about surveillance and what you can do in the workplace and what you can't. And so there's some new requirements here. One of them is, so this AB 1883 says that you can't use workplace surveillance tools with AI on employees that read emotions or collect neural data.

I am not, I do not miss the irony of the fact that I went to Claude to say, what is an example of a workplace surveillance tool that reads emotions and neural data? And I had to stop myself from going out as a rebel. And depending on the industry you guys are in, you may know this already, but apparently there's this whole world of, like in the construction industry, for example, there are helmets now that have sensors that pick up on fatigue and things like that for workplace safety reasons.

So if you are using anything like that, then it is worth looking into this bill more and finding out if what you are using falls under this category and what you can and can't do. But that was an interesting whole new world to me that I did not know existed. So be aware of that.

AB 1331 also says that you can't use workplace surveillance tools in bathrooms, which is interesting to me because it's kind of always been the case since there have been regulations on this, that you can't put surveillance cameras in bathrooms, for example, or areas where employees expect privacy or might change. But this is kind of saying it's recognizing that in the world we're in now, there are portable surveillance tools like those helmets I just talked about, or maybe a driver who has to carry a little, I don't know, tablet that also tracks GPS, those types of things. Workers are allowed to leave those things outside the restroom when they use the restroom.

So if you have any written policies, you may want to update that or practices. And then there's of course penalties, I guess, for making them use their surveillance tools in the bathroom. Just don't do that.

And then finally, we're throwing in this last one, SB 690. I won't spend much time on it, but there has been a huge wave of demand letters going out and lawsuits filed against employers on their websites basically related to, you know, do you have the cookies thing that pops up or don't you? And it's under, I could go down a rabbit hole and I will spare you all, but essentially it comes from these really kind of archaic laws related to wiretaps and other electronic surveillance things.

And some very creative plaintiffs have found a way to send demand letters and file lawsuits over it. And the California legislature kind of put a kibosh on that, which was, I mean, I love it when I can bring you all good news. This is, if you have been hit by this and I have many clients, there is a particular not represented plaintiff who has been sending, I can't even count how many clients I know who have gotten letters from this guy.

So if you got a letter from that guy and you got it within the past two years, this law now wipes out almost everything he's claiming in that letter. Let's put it that way. So it gets rid of this claim.

If you don't know what I'm talking about at all, just delete the last 30 seconds from your memory because it's pretty irrelevant to you. I am going to take a quick look in Q&A. I think we're okay.

So we'll just keep moving and then I'll, if there's anything to answer in the chat, I will. And of course we'll have time at the end, but I think that I am now handing it over to Elizabeth, right? I think you're taking this next part.

All right.

[Elizabeth Levy] (19:50 - 24:16)
Well, thank you, Melissa. And hi everybody. For anybody who doesn't know me, I'm a partner in the Advice and Counsel Group and also the Wage and Hour Group.

So I deal with those scary PAGA cases and all kinds of fun wage and hour issues that pop up. So we could probably talk about all these things for an hour each and I will spare everybody, but there are a couple noteworthy things this year that came around in terms of contracts and arbitration. So first one real quick, AB 1697, basically it's stay or pay, take two.

So you may remember last year there were reforms that came into place that put limitations and specific requirements on bonuses, basically sign-on bonuses, tuition repayments. There were some rules that went into place. There was some industry pushback.

This is a do-over. There's some softening. It's an urgency bill.

So normally bills come into effect January 1st if it's extra super duper important to the legislature or folks at large, it can get signed and put in effect earlier. This one went into effect September 30th. And one of the things it does is push back liability for stay or pay provisions until 2027.

And there are some carve-outs for the financial industry, certain types of bonuses that you see in place there. There are some new carve-outs in place there. One of the interesting things that this law does is remove the at-the-time-of-hire language from the earlier version of the law.

So this could apply to things like, you know, as opposed to just a sign-on bonus, now maybe things like retention bonuses or other types of compensation can come into play. And there's also some carve-outs in terms of when, if PTO is advanced, there's some ways to potentially get some of that back or have carve-outs in terms of the stay or pay types of bonuses and setups. So at a high level, if you have these types of programs, if you have any type of program along the lines of, you know, if you stay with us for X amount of time, you get this bonus.

And if you don't stay, you got to pay it back. Anything like that, you want to take a close look at it. And even though you just looked at it last year, now you got to look at it again for the makeover, make sure that it's compliant.

And maybe there are some carve-outs that are applicable to your industry that possibly you can take advantage of. And so another big area, and it's sort of, it's big if it affects you. This is a little bit in the weeds in terms of arbitration agreements.

So, I mean, arbitration, I could talk, I could talk about arbitration agreements for three hours, but I won't do that to anybody. The big takeaway here is that if the Federal Arbitration Act, if an agreement was not fine under the Federal Arbitration Act, you could have the California Arbitration Act as a backup. So say for whatever reason, the FAA didn't apply, you could have a backup.

That doesn't exist under this new change in the law. So where this really comes into play is, what my take is, is that this is really going to come into play the most with folks that are transportation workers, which, and I think that we talk about this a little bit more, yeah. So transportation workers, there's an exemption to the FAA, and it's not as simple as it sounds.

It's not just like, oh, I drive a truck, or even I work for a trucking company. It's really nuanced. It depends on exactly what you're doing.

There are some cases that I don't love out of the Ninth Circuit. There was one that came out where basically a warehouse worker was found to be a transportation worker because they were making things in a line of commerce. So this is a very, very fact-specific inquiry, and if you have folks that may be on the line, or maybe the line's a little fuzzy or gray, you want to take a close look to see if those agreements will really stand, and take a look at job responsibilities.

Maybe there may be things you want to adjust in terms of your agreements or possibly job responsibilities, but it's one of those things that may not be a big deal for a lot of folks, but if you have folks that may be transportation workers, you're going to want to take a really close look at that. And then with that, I'm going to hand it back over to Angela.

[Angela Rho] (24:16 - 31:29)
Thanks, Elizabeth. A quick shout out to our marketing team who made these slides look so great and relevant, so thank you to them. All right, leave and benefits, everybody's favorite.

So the theme in leave law for this upcoming year is a broader definition of family. SB 1149, as you can see, lets employees take bereavement leave for the death of a designated person, defined as somebody related by blood or having a family relationship, right, equivalent to family. Employers can limit employees to one designated person for every 12-month period, so we recommend building a simple designation form and tracking it.

Of course, bereavement leave is still up to five days and job protected. SB 590, which you see here, passed last year, but it adds the same designated person concept to paid family leave wage replacement benefits, and that begins July of 2028. I know we're not even in 2027, but bear with me, this is just a nice little thing to have in the back of your mind.

But ultimately, the advice that we would give or the recommendation is to update both policies in one go, right, just do it, do it and be done. To add a wrench in this, though, because, you know, California wouldn't be California without adding a little bit of confusion, the definition of a designated person under California paid sick leave is different. There, it's any person identified by the employee at the time the employee requests paid sick leave.

So, if you take anything away from this, just take away, like, oh, okay, there are different definitions for designated person. Next slide. Folks, this is not a bill.

This is a regulation, proposed pregnancy rules, but it's worth spending some time on. So, ears open, stick with me here. On October 16th, so last month, the California Civil Rights Department's Civil Rights Council proposed changes to California's pregnancy leave and accommodation rules so that it matches and in many ways exceeds the Federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.

Nothing is final yet, so please don't worry. Nothing is final, but comments are due by 5 p.m. on December 8th when the public hearing will be held. For those of you, my HR professionals on the call in particular, who are familiar with the Federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, you will see a lot of clear similarities here, right?

Really quickly, the coverage issue pregnancy would include past and potential or intended pregnancies, right? That could include infertility treatment, contraception. Also, the related conditions list is non-exhaustive, excuse me.

So, unnamed conditions could still apply here. Accommodations-wise, there are new accommodations options, which include telework, remote work, changes to how the work is performed, and even temporarily suspending essential functions, right? So, again, this aligns very closely with the Federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, so that shouldn't be a big surprise to anybody.

When it comes to speed and paperwork issues, employers now need to respond as soon as practicable instead of what was previously said, you can respond within 10 days. So, we're just speeding some of that up. And then as for leave, for pregnancy disability leave in California, the 30-day notice requirement would go away.

Instead, employees must give reasonable notice, right? Whatever reasonable is. And so, it just, again, I can't stress it enough, but it really does align more with the Federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.

Now, the funny point about that is that the EEOC indicated just recently that they plan to narrow its PWFA Pregnant Workers Fairness Act regulations by rolling a few things back, such as like the definition of a related medical condition, and broadening certain exemptions, like the religious exemption. So, keep an eye out. I'm curious to see how that's going to work out with everything that's happened post-election.

So, just keep an eye out for that. As a practical point, you're going to want to decide whether to comment on this proposed change here, review your accommodation response times, your medical note practices, and review your leave forms now. Again, much of this tracks the PWFA.

Just real quick, this is what, you know, as discussed in this previous slide, and the proposed regulations have not taken effect, but be ready, right? Be ready. Okay.

From pregnancy to wage an hour, that's quite the jump. This should be the simplest action item for your day, right? You're welcome.

It's very simple, straightforward. State minimum wage rises to $17.40 per hour beginning January 1 of the new year, which necessarily means that the minimum annual salary for most of your exempt employees will rise to $72,384. It's double the state minimum wage.

Recommendation is to check anyone, any employee that is close to that threshold, and check it now so you're not jumping around to reclassify people on December 31. AB 2646 also sets a $19.75, excuse me, hourly minimum for approved agricultural employees and corresponding employees. If this is, you know, relevant to you and your business, call us.

We can talk about it, but just keep that $19.75 in mind, excuse me. There's also a higher overtime exemption hourly rate for your computer software people, employees, and it's now $61.03. Again, that also means that the minimum annual salary requirements for those employees will also increase. And then, key reminder here, many cities that you have employees and have higher local minimum hourly wages.

So, please keep an eye on that as well. If you have a question, let us know. We are happy to look into it, but those typically will adjust either January 1 or July 1 as well.

[Elizabeth Levy] (31:30 - 31:44)
Okay. And Angela, I'm just going to quick shout out for healthcare industry on top of the computer exemption. There's always something.

There's always something ticky-tacky in the wage and hour realm. So, just make sure you keep your eye on all the minimum wage raises and exempt raises.

[Angela Rho] (31:45 - 31:45)
You're absolutely right.

[Elizabeth Levy] (31:46 - 31:46)
Yeah.

[Angela Rho] (31:46 - 31:48)
Fast food too, right? Yeah.

[Elizabeth Levy] (31:48 - 31:49)
Fast food has it all too. Yeah.

[Angela Rho] (31:50 - 34:37)
There's currently no scheduled increase for fast food, but the fast food council may approve one. So, we'll keep an eye on that as well. But thank you for that, ladies.

All right. Ah, these next two laws. They work together.

SB 1237, raise the civil penalty for repeat failures to file a paid data report. Those penalties went up from $200 to $1,000 per employee. And that's, again, for repeat failures.

The first failure to file, geez, remains at $100. So, there's that, right? Last year's SB 464, as you see 2025 there, made those penalties mandatory and it expanded the report from 10 to 23 job categories beginning in 2027.

So, HR professionals, good luck with that. Please reach out. We're happy to help you figure out that landmine.

Um, but we recommend mainly the big takeaway here. Recommend that you start mapping those job titles now, right? Don't wait until April because it is always a rush.

And we don't want you to inadvertently leave a category out. And then the final wage and hour slag. Yes, we can all cheer for that.

Um, two smaller items that are really worth noting here, just to take away. SB 1444 is an omnibus bill and it lets individual employees recover labor code civil penalties for willful independent contractor misclassification. Keep that in mind.

And SB 1316, it was actually signed in August. And what it essentially does is it says that if the labor commissioner asks for payroll or time records and you as the employer just don't produce them or don't produce them on time, you now can't use those records later on in certain hearings, right? These hearings include labor commissioner hearings on claims for retaliation, discrimination, wage and hour violations.

So really pay attention, produce them on time. But SB 1316 also lets wage judgment liens be removed. So what is the practical takeaway here?

Respond to records requests, timely and complete like fully. All right. And I am passing this on now to Melissa to discuss discrimination, retaliation, and training.

[Melissa Whitehead] (34:38 - 43:32)
All right. Thank you. Thank you.

We'll get into some juicier topics in my opinion. Not that wage an hour is not thrilling. Um, everybody there's what's the, there's a lid to every pot or whatever that is, but this is more of my jam.

So let's talk about discrimination, retaliation and training and some new developments there. Um, uh, something, something sort of interesting if you are legal nerds like we are, and I suspect I'm in somewhat like company with some of the HR folks and other attorneys on the call. Um, but it probably doesn't have a huge practical impact on your businesses.

Um, California sort of recognize that there are so many different there's labor code, there's civil code, you know, government code FEHA there's all these different bills, uh, all defining sex discrimination differently. And so this bill was passed to essentially say, here's the one definition and every, not every, most bills that define sex discrimination now have the same, including um, it includes things like not conforming to sex or gender stereotypes, pregnancy or related medical conditions, gender identity, all the things that we're probably used to including in our EEO statement or, um, you know, in our handbooks and things like that.

It's just now going to apply across the board of most, uh, statutes that use the phrase sex discrimination. Um, and of course those in this, I always love when they throw in this like language at the end, that's like, and by the way, read this broadly. So if you're not sure if something is sex discrimination, it probably is.

That's kind of what they're trying to get at there. Um, there was a bill that passed that, excuse me, that was vetoed that would have specifically added menopause to the definition to FEHA definition of sex. When it talks about sex discrimination, pregnancy related conditions, et cetera.

One of the conditions then listed would have been menopause. Um, and I, I know you're like, why are you telling me about things that didn't happen that were vetoed? And there's a couple of reasons.

One of them is if you really are a nerd, like we are, and you are going to look at the statutory language of AB 2563, it's very confusing because there's different triggering language. They were hinged together. So if AB 1940 passed, this was going to be the definition.

If it didn't pass, this is the definition. That's what that means. But I also don't want people to misread this headline if they see it anywhere and think, okay, menopause isn't protected because it probably already is, right?

It's a health condition. People probably can get accommodations or leave even if they get the certification and they're eligible for leaves. So don't, um, I don't know.

I don't, I don't, I guess I don't really know anybody who would be like celebrating that menopause wasn't protected, but just assume it still is. It's just not expressly in the definition of sex discrimination. Um, so based on this, you may want to update EEO policy language, um, depending on your, uh, most likely if you are somebody who, uh, we've done your handbook, you probably don't need to update the sex discrimination or the sex description there.

Um, but there have been changes over the years. So you may want to, and then, um, again, like I said, still know that you must accommodate, uh, menopause symptoms through the interactive process. It's just not expressly protected under FEHA.

Um, this is an interesting one. Um, so this new bill passed about related to immigration retaliation and what the law itself says is that employers, um, cannot tie a worker's perceived immigration status in a way to something that would discourage them using workplace rights. And so an example of that, I feel like maybe this is just me.

I feel like that is phrased very confusing. I almost can't even understand what they're trying to ban with that language. So here's an example.

I think I didn't write the law, but here's an example that I think would trigger this would be, um, somebody saying, you know, say a worker comes, this is kind of a monstrous example, I'll be honest, but it's what came to mind. Um, somebody comes in and says, Hey, I've got this, you know, I, I missed my meal periods and I didn't get paid premiums. I need you to fix it for me.

And the worker says, well, or the HR person or whoever says, well, gosh, yeah, you could file a wage and hour claim, but I've heard that ICE has been hanging out at the labor commissioner's office and really auditing those records for people who are filing claims because you perceive that that person is maybe undocumented or something like, or their visa expired or something like that. Right. That would be now prohibited expressly under, um, this bill.

So it covers applicants, former employees, um, and all of that. And I will say, I guess that was a sort of monstrous example, but I could also see it going the other way. I always try to think of these examples in a more generous way to the employers, because I feel like, you know, you guys are on this webinar.

You're trying to stay up to date. You're probably the type who's trying to do things right. And you're probably not the type to say threatened potential deportation over wage and hour complaints.

Um, but I could see somebody getting themselves in hot water with good intentions by saying a similar thing of, yeah, you're right. You do have the right to do that. I just want to make sure you do know though, that I heard that ICE is really auditing that or, you know, whatever it might be, I could see somebody getting themselves in hot water with good intentions.

So just be mindful of that, train your supervisors, because they're the ones who are going to be the front line for a lot of this. Um, they shouldn't be making comments. They shouldn't be asking for papers.

You know, if there's any work authorization, authorization issues, run it through HR. Don't have your supervisors handling that. Um, make sure you're sending those SB 294, know your rights notices.

Um, they had to be sent out last year, but there it's an annual requirement. So depending on when you sent it, you almost certainly need to send a new one by February 1st. Um, there are violations for this, uh, $10,000 per person.

Um, and you know, I will note this bill specifically says perceived immigration status. I think it would be best to assume that this would also apply if you know the person's immigration status and you do this, that that's also probably a problem, right? I mean, that's probably already protected under the protected classes of FEHA and all of that, but I just want to make that distinction fairly clear.

Um, okay. Training and training records. Uh, the new law this year is that the, uh, you know, the, the, the training session that your employees are just so excited for every two years that they're emailing you and they're like, when's it time?

Do we get to do that training again? That training has more requirements. Um, the harassment training now has to cover recognizing reporting and confronting hate speech based on protected traits.

Um, again, they love to keep us on our toes. They love to give lawyers job security. Hate speech is not defined.

They don't say really what it is in there. What they do say, um, is that the training should teach about workplace speech that vilifies humiliates or incites hatred against people based on FEHA protected traits. Um, so, you know, if you do your own training internally, make sure it's included, make sure when you're talking to vendors about your next round of training, whenever that is that they are aware of and including that, because again, even if you use vendors, keep in mind, you are responsible for making sure your employees are getting compliant training.

I will just give the tiniest of promos to, there's a couple of us here who doing these trainings is like our love language. We love doing these. I especially love coming to your place of work and doing them in person, but I'll step aside and move on from that.

But if you're interested, hit us up. Um, and then I also want to take this. It's related.

I want to use this opportunity to remind you guys of the law that went into effect this last January. And we talked about it in our webinar last year, but keep in mind, I'm bringing this up because I handle a lot of our clients get record requests for personnel records, and I'm not seeing many of these training records in those personnel files. So I'm flagging this for you guys that your training records now are to be kept in the personnel file and they should show the employee's name, the trainer provider, the date and the duration of the training core competencies covered.

And if there's any certification, those details should all be in personnel files, but that's not new this year. It was new in January. Okay.

[Elizabeth Levy] (43:33 - 44:07)
Um, oh, I thought I had, yes, I'm going to say quick, quick plug on the wage and hour front. If you have something in there, if you're, if your employees are getting trained on wage and hour things, that's wonderful. That's great.

And you want to make sure it's in there and make sure that if some plaintiff attorney is fishing around that you can hand over a personnel file where looky here, this person, you know, look at them. They got a hundred percent on this quiz. They got this training and they know about meal breaks and rest breaks and reporting like whatever it may be.

So reminder to make sure they get away into the file.

[Melissa Whitehead] (44:09 - 49:09)
Totally. I love, like I said, I help a lot of clients with these records requests and my favorite day is when I'm producing a file where the first thing I have is a signed arbitration agreement. The second through however many things I have are all the certifications of, oh look, I got trained on my meal and rest period compliance.

I got trained on this and it really, I, I actually don't know if this is true, but I like to believe it just takes the wins out of the opposing council sales. So yes, great point. Thank you.

Okay. Shifting gears to workplace safety and violence, a couple of developments in that area this year. Hopefully this does not apply to many, but if you've ever had to try to pursue a workplace violence restraining order, you know that that is not a task for the faint of heart.

It's a very tedious process and the law is finally starting to change to make it a little less so. Generally speaking, not generally speaking, but now under before this new law, if you wanted to pursue a workplace violence restraining order on behalf of one of your employees, say there was a threat in the workplace, something like that, you have to pick a person that you're trying to get protected. And then you say, and the rest of the workplace, but there has to be a person that as of January one is no longer true.

You can now file a petition for your work site. You don't need an individual name. And the time to pursue this is generally when either violence or a credible threat targets the workplace generally.

So you're getting a threat to the workplace where you are not a person, but the workplace. Also another interesting, and again, if you've never had to live this experience of trying to get a workplace violence restraining order, this might seem relatively minor to you, but if you have, you know, it's not, they now will be allowing as of January one, 2028. I don't know why they need a year to prepare for this change, but here we are.

They will be allowing free remote appearances for petitioners, witnesses, and everyone, which is a big deal because the process of getting the workplace violence restraining order part of what makes it so onerous is you a lot, a lot of counties, you have to actually file it in person. And then you have to be there. There's just a whole lot of in-person requirements.

And so now you can be there remotely, which is also nice when you have the employee who doesn't want to be in person in the courtroom with the person you're filing their restraining order against. It's nice to have the remote option. So the takeaways there are to add group petitions.

If you've got that sort of template or kind of checklist of options, make sure you have that in your kind of toolbox, decide in advance who should be authorizing these types of filing against probably somebody in HR or HR equivalent and keep your incident logs current, have them filled out as contemporaneously as possible because they're going to be your evidence. If you're required to, so that's the reason number one, second reason, they will be your evidence for these types of restraining orders. And then last one for me here.

So this is just a fun little note is that Cal OSHA, oh boy, I just filtered so many negative comments out. This is like emotional growth in real time, guys. Cal OSHA has now said that they can call criminal prosecutors.

There's sort of automatic triggers now. If there are incidents where five or more workers are seriously injured or exposed, or if there's any death, prosecutors are supposed to be automatically notified by Cal OSHA. I am fascinated in a mostly academic way to see how this plays out.

Gently put, Cal OSHA is not known for being super quick to respond to things. So I'm curious to see how this automatic notice happens, but nonetheless, you should be aware that that is, so something happens like truly horrible in your workplace, know that that's a piece. So you may want to also contact criminal counsel or find specialists early, just so you're sort of prepared for that.

They've also added some criminal consequences to willfully interfering with Cal OSHA. That's always been there, but now it reaches serious injury, illness, exposure, etc. So make sure you've got an inspection protocol in place.

Make sure you're cooperating. Make sure if you have this type of workplace that whoever would be the front line for an unnoticed inspection knows who they should go to immediately, knows how to document things, and again, call counsel early after serious incidents. Because in theory, it now is going to get into the criminal world as well.

That doesn't sound quite right. The criminal law world as well. Okay, and then I am kicking it back to Elizabeth to equally juicy topics of PAGA and litigation.

[Elizabeth Levy] (49:10 - 58:22)
So I, you know, I know Wage and Hour is not everybody's favorite. I'm going to kind of cut through here. Again, I could talk about PAGA for a very, very long time, and I will not do that to you guys.

These are just some quick numbers. If you have not experienced a PAGA lawsuit, you're super lucky. I will knock on wood for you that it doesn't happen, but the odds are that if you do business in California long enough, it's one of those things that unfortunately will probably come your way.

You know, the best thing you can do is sort of have your metaphorical seat belt on to be, you know, be ready for impact if and when it happens. So these are just some numbers to give you a sense. 400% increase in PAGA cases in the last 10 years.

There are a few, we call them frequent flyers. There are a few firms we see all the time. They file a ton of cases.

I'll get into some regulations designed to kind of sort of address that. 20, 25, over 23,000, or I'm sorry, 2,300 cases. You know, average settlement, and I could talk about this for a long time.

There are so many things that go into what makes a settlement. It depends on how many people, and what the violations look like, and what the theories look like, and opposing counsel, and there are, it's a soup with many different ingredients, but just some high-level numbers. As much as PAGA may be sort of this like elephant in the room that everybody wants to sort of ignore and not talk about because it's, you know, it can be very boring, and also sort of terrifying at the same time.

It's just something that should be on folks' radars. And, you know, at a really, really, really high level, there's, you know, there are class actions, and then there are PAGA actions, and we often see them go in tandem. So it's, the class actions can go back four years, PAGA action goes back a year, and they all march forward until there's a judgment or a settlement.

So, you know, liability goes on until the case resolves in one way or the other. And about 99.7, I think, is the number of these cases resolve because of so many different reasons, the high exposure, and fee shifting, and all that. So in terms of the updates this year, so PAGA's been around for a while.

PAGA's, like, PAGA's old enough to vote now, I guess, if it were a person. But in 2024, there were some, you know, it was a pretty significant update. It was amended.

You know, we talked about this a little bit last year, but just as a reminder, there were some pretty significant amendments. And one of those things is that if employers are doing everything they, you know, everything they can possibly do ahead of time, there's an avenue to reduce penalties. So the language, there's a penalty reduction that comes into play when employers seek to comply within 60 days of notice of a PAGA lawsuit.

And if they're doing reasonable steps before the notice, they can have a reduction down to, you know, 15% of what the potential penalties would be. The default for most PAGA penalties is $100 per employee per violation. There's some types of, some causes of action can go a little higher, a little lower.

But, you know, the default is typically $100 per pay period per employee per violation. If there are some arguments that we see on the other side in terms of getting that number higher, if it's what, you know, a subsequent violation, that's a really academic debate. I have strong opinions in case law to back me up on that, but general default.

So in terms of reasonable steps to do proactively, you know, having payroll audits, having lawful policies in place, training supervisors, training managers, training employees, getting those certificates, putting them in the personnel file like Melissa was talking about, those are ways that you can sort of proactively try to, you know, hopefully reduce liability if you are in a situation where you're dealing with a PAGA lawsuit. It's a, you know, there's tools at your disposal.

So in terms of this year, what we're seeing is sort of over the last, you know, couple years now is sort of how things are shaking out post those amendments. So after those amendments, there were some proposed regulations that were issued earlier this year. And those regulations had certain requirements for some of those frequent flyer firms and individuals that file a ton of PAGA letters.

There were some proposed regulations surrounding how you can structure a settlement post mediation. And then what we saw was in August, so there was a public comment period, and then in August, there was another round of proposed regulations that sort of shaved off some of the edges of the initial round. So we're sort of in this, a little bit of a limbo where we have these proposed regulations, but we're not 100% sure which ones are going to stick.

It's possible they could be finalized later this year, early 2027. We're sort of just keeping an eye out. So the takeaway is, if you are in an active PAGA lawsuit now, which hopefully you're not, but if you are, keep in mind the fact that these regulations are changing a little bit and what you, particularly what you can and can't do in a settlement context, may be coming into play a little bit more.

And then this last bullet point that I have here is a really weird one. And again, something I could probably talk about for long enough to really bore everybody, but there's this concept of a headless PAGA claim. So a couple of years ago, you may remember the United States Supreme Court issued Viking River.

It was a really big landmark decision, and it kind of came up with, it kind of created this idea of an individual PAGA claim. And so the California courts have been batting this around and trying to figure out what the heck this means. And so there's a split in authority right now in terms of whether a plaintiff can assert a PAGA claim on behalf of other employees without also having an individual PAGA claim.

And this gets really, really ticky tacky and gets into some of the newer standing requirements that were put into place in the 2024 law. It's kind of really a very academic issue in question at this point, but it's just something to keep in mind if you find yourself in a PAGA lawsuit. And also something to potentially keep in mind if you're taking a look at arbitration agreements.

You want to make sure that your arbitration agreements have language that's set up the way that you would want to either arbitrate or not arbitrate things. You just want to take a look. I would say, have counsel take a look at arbitration agreements through the lens of PAGA and through the lens of what in the world is going on with the possibility of these headless PAGA cases.

I mean, to me personally, I read some of these decisions, and it's like there's some really, really just, I think, tortured reasoning in some of them. But the idea that you can have what's supposed to be a representative action going ahead without the individual having an individual claim that mirrors the people they're trying to represent, to me, it seems a little bonkers. But California law, especially in the wage and market context, is often bonkers.

And so with that, I think we are, yeah, we're done. Nearly done. We've talked so fast on about a lot of things.

So Angela, I'm going to kick it, I'm going to kick it back to you. And I don't know if you want to do the CLE code real quick. I will.

So the CLE code, for those of you who may need CLE here, it's pending. And I'm going to put an email address in the chat and just not to confuse folks more. So I am Elizabeth Levy.

Elizabeth Holmes is the person on our end who's going to handle getting CLE certificates out, et cetera, if and when we get to that point. So I'm going to put her info in there. But just reminder, she is helping out on the admin side of this.

She's not an attorney. She's going to help out with the CLE component. Please don't confuse the two of us, although she's super lovely.

So if you do think that I am her, then great. But I'll put her email address in there. And the CLE code that we have for today is [code shared with live attendees].

So email her that code. I'll put that code and her email address in the chat. Fingers crossed we get CLE.

And if you have questions about that, you can ping her about that as well. Okay. Now, Angela, I will fully kick it back over to you.

[Angela Rho] (58:23 - 59:36)
So Elizabeth, yes, CLE code [code shared with live attendees], another reminder. And mark your calendars. This is the timeline on one slide.

Take the picture. Move on. We're good with this one.

Just keep, folks, we're in November. So just keep that in mind. This is the one slide you're going to want.

And then finally, here's your to do list. Ten action items, roughly in the order of urgency within each column. Okay.

I know I said we're going to wrap up with Q&A. We literally have one minute. So let's go.

Who has a question? Let's pop in the chat. I think we've gotten to a lot of your questions in the Q&A box.

So thank you all. Can I go back a slide? Josh, yes, absolutely.

Did we want that or did we want the other slide? And just a reminder, folks, you will get the materials emailed to you hopefully by the end of the week. So okay.

Yes, that one. Thanks, Josh. Andrea, the email is in the other chat.

I'm putting it in the chat right now.

[Melissa Whitehead] (59:36 - 1:00:25)
I just put it in the chat. I think yours says that only hosts and panelists can see it. So I just put it to everyone.

Oh, thank you. I got you. I got you.

Thank you. Thank you. Her email, Elizabeth Holmes, the email address for the CLE and the code is all in the chat now.

So everyone should be able to see it. I can answer a quick question. I see a question that says how often do we need to do the hate speech trainings?

I'm taking that one because that's an easy softball that I take real quick. That just needs to be included in the anti the harassment prevention training that you already have to do every two years. It's a new requirement for that training.

So that's the one that's what it's an hour for non-supervisors, two hours for supervisors. You're doing it every two years and upon hire. It's just a new requirement in that.

[Angela Rho] (1:00:27 - 1:00:50)
Perfect. All right. Please feel free to reach out to any of us with any additional questions.

I'm going to try to get you over there. Here's our contact information. Thank you all for being such an engaged group.

And thank you, Melissa and Elizabeth for co-hosting this. All right, everybody. Thank you.

Other Webinars

Ready to Strengthen
Your Employment Practices?

Have a question about what you watched, or want to talk through your own situation? Our team is here to help.

Contact Us ›

Or email us at info@medinamckelvey.com